Friday, May 25, 2007

Critical Analysis of Dawkins

"There is little point in arguing with such fundamentalist nonsense. It's about as worthwhile as trying to persuade a flat-earther that the world is actually round."

These are just some of the attacks on Richard Dawkins contained in Alister McGrath's critical analysis of Dawkins' book "The God Delusion". Alister McGrath, who is a former athiest, is a biochemist and Professor of Historical Theology at Oxford University, which makes him more than capable of making arguments against Richard Dawkins work.

Here are just a few of the opening paragraphs of his analysis:

Until recently, western atheism had waited patiently, believing that belief in God would simply die out. But now, a whiff of panic is evident. Far from dying out, belief in God has rebounded, and seems set to exercise still greater influence in both the public and private spheres. The God Delusion expresses this deep anxiety, partly reflecting an intense distaste for religion. Yet there is something deeper here, often overlooked in the heat of debate. The anxiety is that the coherence of atheism itself is at stake. Might the unexpected resurgence of religion persuade many that atheism itself is fatally flawed as a worldview?

That's what Dawkins is worried about. The shrill, aggressive rhetoric of his God Delusion masks a deep insecurity about the public credibility of atheism. The God Delusion seems more designed to reassure atheists whose faith is faltering than to engage fairly or rigorously with religious believers, and others seeking for truth. (Might this be because the writer is himself an atheist whose faith is faltering?) Religious believers will be dismayed by its ritual stereotyping of religion, and will find its manifest lack of fairness a significant disincentive to take its arguments and concerns seriously. Seekers after truth who would not consider themselves religious may also find themselves shocked by Dawkins' aggressive rhetoric, his substitution of personal creedal statements for objective engagement with evidence, his hectoring and bullying tone towards "dyed-in-the-wool faith-heads," and his utter determination to find nothing but fault with religion of any kind.

It is this deep, unsettling anxiety about the future of atheism which explains the high degree of dogmatism and aggressive rhetorical style of this new secular fundamentalism. The dogmatism of the work has been the subject of intense criticism in the secular press, reflecting growing alarm within the secularist community about the damage that Dawkins is doing to their public reputation. Many of those who might be expected to support Dawkins are running for cover, trying to distance themselves from this embarrassment.

To give an example: The God Delusion trumpets the fact that its author was recently voted one of the world's three leading intellectuals. This survey took place among the readers of Prospect magazine in November 2005. So what did this same Prospect magazine make of the book? Its reviewer was shocked at this "incurious, dogmatic, rambling, and self-contradictory" book. The title of the review? "Dawkins the dogmatist."

McGrath misses nothing while dissecting "The God Delusion". He even makes a point of explaining the embarassment of the Athiest community, quoting Athiest Philospher Michael Ruse:
"The God Delusion makes me embarrassed to be an atheist."

Here is the entire article if you'd like to take a look
Alister McGrath is now the author of 2 books that critize Richard Dawkins works.

Dawkins' God: Genes, Memes, and the Meaning of Life
The Dawkins Delusion?: Athiest Fundamentalism and the denial of the divine

ELIA responds to the RRS/WOTM debate

Well although I had heard that the Rational Response Squad vs Way of the Master debate would be available tomorrow, I was flooded by atheists sending us the debate via youtube. So in this blog, we will address key points made by both sides, the outcome of the debate and what people should be left thinking after such a debate!

Firstly though, if you haven't seen the debate, you should watch it here.

Alright! I hope you enjoyed it because I certainly did!

Well the video starts up with the Atheists acting about as Rational as they get! Mr. Sapient and the gang claim that they are "going to go end religion"! Well.. that is a hardy statement that many have made before! Even Voltaire (click "search books" at the top and click the link you get) made such a claim! And I'm quite sure Voltaire was more capable of doing so then the Rational Response Squad.. but let's get on with it!

Well the debate starts with Ray Comfort making the claim that because paintings have painters, and buildings have builders, this wonderfully structured universe must indeed have a Creator.. At this point, the person who posted the video writes across the bottom "Actually it's [the painting] is only proof that there is a painting"..

While I don't know who this person is, s/he might want to take that bit of information to the police departments of the world! Because if s/he believes that it is not logical to believe there is a painter behind every painting (no.. not literally BEHIND the painting) then s/he might want to tell police that it is illogical to assume that footprints at the scene of a crime came from feet.. or that fingerprints came from fingers! The world of investigation will be turned upside by this new realization!

So yes, just wanted to comment on that.. But then Ray Comfort goes on to talk about the 10 Commandments and how we all (of course) fall so short of perfection. Now this is a major turning point of the debate (because it sways the audience) and it is one of the biggest Straw-Man arguments I have ever seen!

Brian Sapient stands up and says he should just walk out of the room because Ray Comfort spoke about the 10 Commandments.. Now because Ray Comfort and Kirk Cameron promised that they could prove that God existed without using the Bible, Brian Sapient claims they failed.. having spoken about the 10 Commandments in their speech.. Did you guys see the Straw Man?.. Ok here it is..

Kirk Cameron and Ray Comfort never said they wouldn't talk about the Bible or anything inside of it! They only promised that they could prove God's existence without using the Bible. Here's the proof of that. They never at all claim that they won't mention the Bible during their speech, only that "we can prove that God exists, scientifically, absolutely, without mentioning faith or even the Bible." Which they did (or attempted to do, whichever way you look at it)

So Brian Sapient is either a liar, or he was ignorant. You pick!

So Brian Sapient tries to claim that the "building = builder" argument doesn't work because "we can call the builder" and "we can call NYC to look up the permit records" but, "we can't call God to visit His universe factory"..

Now, again either Brain Sapient is being purposely deceptive or he's ignorant (again, you pick!) but his argument is completely untrue. Just because we cannot contact (through direct means) the Creator of the universe, it does not mean that there is no Creator! Let's see if Sapients logic works on other situations..

I wake up on the day of my birthday and find birthday balloons in my room.. I look for a birthday card, but none can be found.. There is NO PROOF that someone left the balloons in my room, besides the fact that the balloons are in fact in my room.. should I then conclude that the balloons were ALWAYS in my room?.. no Mr. Sapient, that doesn't work..

another analogy just for fun!

I buy a flower pot and a pot of dirt.. and keep it in my room.. after a few days of me being to lazy to go get flower seeds, I see a little sprout.. Now, there's no reason for me to think that someone planted seeds in my flower pot besides the fact that there is in fact something growing.. Do I conclude that there had always existed a sprout inside the dirt? No.. that's irrational..

So I think it's obvious that Mr. Sapient's argument that "because we cannot contact that Creator, the Creator must not exist" is faulty and completely untrue!

Then Mr. Sapient talks about the 1st Law of Thermodynamics (he said 3rd but that's a reasonable mistake.. standing infront of a crowd of people and debating is not the easiest thing to do).. Mr. Sapient says "it's one of the most tested laws in science".. (this is obviously not provable, he's just trying to sound intelligent)

Now I agree, blowing up a building does not change the fact that the matter is still there, only now in pieces of rubble rather than a building.. but he goes one step too far and ends up stepping on his own feet!

"That tells us scientifically, if we were to use a more scientific approach".. That sentence just makes me laugh.. but here's where he REALLY steps on his own feet!

"The components of our world today, of our universe today have always existed... All signs point to the fact has just always existed ..."

Really Mr. Sapient? R E A L L Y!?!

Well someone fire Stephen Hawking! He's spreading lies! Because it is a pretty well known fact that in June of 2006 Stephen Hawking came out with amazing evidence that the universe did actually have a beginning.. And most cosmologists are following suit and adapting that theory as fact.. Don't believe me? Read away! Here and here.

Now, unfortunately the debate falls apart at this point because Ray Comfort and Kirk Cameron most likely have no idea about recent science.. (or atleast about this discovery).

The girl who is debating alongside Brian Sapient even says "If God is infinite, why can't the universe be infinite?" and at that she stumps Kirk Cameron..

But she has obviously never learned that "Everything that begins to exist, must have a cause".. God by His very nature is Eternal! Therefore He does not need a cause, but the universe.. which has been proven to begin at a certain point in time, does require a cause (Creator). For more on this, check out Kalaam's Cosmological Argument.

Then, perhaps Sapient realized his argument was poop.. because the RRS then makes the argument about whether or not Christians can do as they please, and still be forgiven! (Keep in mind that this is not the topic of the debate)..

And sinse the RRS is about as keen at interpreting scripture as GodIsImaginary, the only thing that makes them seem like they have the upper hand is the crowd, and the weakness of Kirk and Ray.. (sorry to say it, but they were very submissive during this debate)

Then Ray Comfort talks about the "blind faith" it takes to "quote history books".. which was probably not the best thing for him to say, because it leaps off the topic of the debate. But ELIA agrees, the Bible is the inerrant Word of God and also the History book of the world. We also agree that everyone should be skeptical of everything they read (even in history books and even of the material you get from OUR site as well)!!

Well, during Brian Sapients closing argument he hits a bunch of topics and does really nothing to disprove God's existence (he really only argues the character of God)

So now, after seeing the very weak job done by Ray Comfort and Kirk Cameron.. many Christians may be left wondering "What does this mean?"..

Well it's important to point out a very important fact about debates..

The winner of a debate does not always (but may sometimes and does most of the time) represent the correct idea..

The winner of a debate isn't always the one who is right, but merely the one who had a better debating style (as happened in this debate)..

If anyone wants to believe that this debate proves Atheism as true because Brian Sapient won the debate then I suggest they listen to William Lane Craig's debates.. Because he has beaten more Atheists than I care to count!

Don't lose heart! Because behind Brian Sapient's arguments were lies, rudeness, and a willingness to break the topic of the debate!

While Kirk and Ray might not have looked as good as they could have, we pray that they planted seeds in the hearts of the people who attended the debate!

-Jason, founder of ELIA

ELIA responds to GodIsImaginary (1)

So, we just received this video from DumbReligion. It is from GodIsImaginary. This website contains videos and articles, all of which aim eradicate your belief in Christianity; and a few of them even tell you they'll do it "in less than" a certain amount of time! Unforunately, no free pizza is offered if they can't deliver on this promise.

The video can be seen here. Please take 5 minutes of your time to watch this video before reading out rebuttal.

Here is our rebuttal:
You can prove that this video is completely irrational is less than 5 minutes.

Notice how little knowledge they have of scripture? The Bible is a collection of 66 books and should be read as such. What GodIsImaginary tries to do is pick out specific verses and say, "Here's the whole picture"; but this is not the way to go about interpreting scripture. The way GodIsImaginary interprets scripture is much like a man who comes across Exodus 23:9 and comes to the conclusion that the Bible teaches that people can become tall green men just by moving into Africa! This is how GodIsImaginary interprets the scripture in this video. They completely ignore the fundamental Biblical teaching that we are not tempt God, never try to bargan with Him. Here are just a few verses to show that GodIsImaginary did not do their research:

"Do not test the Lord your God as you did as Massah" Deuteronomy 6:16 (NIV)

"Because you have seen me, you have believed; blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed" John 20:29 (NIV)

Well, there are 2 basic ideas that this video uses to support itself and I will address both.

The first idea that GodIsImaginary stumbles upon is when they get the idea that we will receive anything we wish for, (according to Matthew 18:19-20) just by praying for it. I don't know about any of you, but I don't know any Christians who has left the faith because they didn't get that car or house they prayed for. Or what if Satanists decided to get together and pray that God not exist! What a mess God has gotten Himself into! But see, this isn't how it works; we don't get everything we pray for. GodIsImaginary either doesn't know anything about the Christian faith, or they are purposely deceiving their viewers by claiming that the Bible teaches that every prayer will be answered.

GodIsImaginary really puts all their eggs in one basket with their second idea, stating that God does not exist because Jesus most likely won't appear to you when you pray for Him too (but don't doubt what the Lord can do!)

But what this video chooses to ignore however, is that it is well documented in the Bible that people did see the resurrected Jesus and went around Rome proclaiming that they had seen him. In 1 Corinthians 15:3, Paul even names the order of appearances Jesus made and concludes by saying "most of whom are still alive". The reason Paul finished that way was because he wanted people to know that his claims were not false and that they could be cross-examined by others who had seen the resurrected Christ. If Paul had been lying, it is doubtful that he would have been so specific as to whom Jesus appeared and in what order.

And about those who claimed to see Jesus after His crucifixion; remember that these people did not believe that Jesus would resurrect, nor was there any reason for them to have a sudden burst of faith seeing that they had all fled from the area when Jesus was sentenced to crucifixion.

The fact is that there was a scattering of the disciples once Jesus was arrested, but something happened to make them all bold enough to proclaim a risen Savior.

It is a fact that Saul of Tarsus went from being an executioner of Christians, to the leading Christian evangelist during the time of the Early Church.

If this GodIsImaginary video is going to be taken seriously, then I believe it is their responsibility to supply us with an alternative explanation for the sudden faith and rapid growth of Christianity.

Saying that God does not exist only complicates matters, because I contend that any attempt at a naturalistic explanation of the emergence of the disciples proclaiming a risen Christ actually creates more questions than it answers!

As you have been shown throughout this rebuttal, this video has little truth to offer and has no shame in twisting scripture in order to achieve their own ends.

-Jason, founder of ELIA